I'm making a java program & I want this to be both as server and a client (using sockets). How is this best achieved?
If you mean that you want to both send and receive data, a single regular socket (on each computer) will do just fine. See Socket.getInputStream and Socket.getOutputStream.
The usual "server" / "client" distinction just boils down which host is listening for incoming connections, and which hosts connect to those hosts. Once the connection is setup, you can both send and receive from both ends.
If you want both hosts to listen for incoming connections, then just set up a ServerSocket and call accept on both hosts.
Related links:
Official trail: The Java™ Tutorials, Lesson: All About Sockets
If you want each station to function as a server and a client, like a p2p chat,
you should implement a thread with a ServerSocket, listening for incoming connections, and once it got a connection, open a new thread to handle it so the current one will keep on listening for new connections.
For it to be able to connect to others, simple use SocketAddress and Socket, in a different thread to try to connect to a specified server address (e.g. by a list of the user's friends)
you can find plenty of chat examples by googling.
cheers.
If you want the program to perform the same operations regardless of whether it is a server or a client for a certain connection, I could imagine handing off both the client Socket and the ServerSocket.accept()-produced socket to the same method for processing.
Have a look at jgroups it's a library that allows the creation of groups of processes whose members can send messages to each other. Another option would be to use hazelcast...
You may also look at this question.
The best way to do this is to run the server on a thread:
You run server.accept() therefore while your program is listening for a connection on that thread you can do whatever you want on the main thread, even connect to another server therefore making the program both a server & a client.
Related
I am completely new to creating a network connection in java so I apologize if this is a stupid question.
I am trying to create a D&D companion in java that will allow a player to create their character and then send it to the DM so that they can view it and make changes and send it back to the player. I want to be able to make it so that any time a field is changed on one computer it will also be changed on the other computer.
After a bunch of research online I have been able to create a socket connection between the DM(server) and the player(client) and pass a message between the two but I am not sure how a socket connection works after this initial connection is made. My research has not been very clear on this. I have found many resources that have said that java closes the socket after a message has been passed and many that say that the socket stays open.
If java closes the socket then my problem is easy enough to solve because then I will just have to open a new socket every time I need to pass data making sure that I pass the IP address of the client to the server the first time I make a connection.
My real questions come in when a socket stays open.
If the socket stays open and multiple clients connect to the server, will the server just shout over the network whenever it transmits a message so that all clients receive the message? (If this is the case then I know I can just attach a username to the front of the message so that the client can determine if the server is talking to it.)
If the server does not shout then how do I specify which client I want the server to talk to?
Will I have to add a loop to my receive methods so that the client/server is constantly listening for a transmission from the server/client or will java automatically do so after I run the method the first time?
I have found many resources that have said that java closes the socket after a message has been passed
You found them where?
and many that say that the socket stays open.
All those are correct. Java never closes connections. The application closes connections.
If java closes the socket then my problem is easy enough to solve because then I will just have to open a new socket every time I need to pass data making sure that I pass the IP address of the client to the server the first time I make a connection.
It doesn't.
My real questions come in when a socket stays open.
If the socket stays open and multiple clients connect to the server, will the server just shout over the network whenever it transmits a message so that all clients receive the message?
No. It will respond via the socket that is connected to the corresponding client.
(If this is the case then I know I can just attach a username to the front of the message so that the client can determine if the server is talking to it.)
Unnecessary.
If the server does not shout then how do I specify which client I want the server to talk to?
The server responds via the same socket it read the request from.
Will I have to add a loop to my receive methods so that the client/server is constantly listening for a transmission from the server/client
No, you will have to add a thread per accepted socket, that loops reading requests until end of stream.
or will java automatically do so after I run the method the first time?
No.
You seem to have been reading some truly appalling drivel. Take a look at the Custom Networking section of the Java Tutorial.
Adding to EJP's wise answer, it might be worth clarifying:
Sounds like you (wisely) use TCP, so your Socket represents a connection between 1 server and 1 client. No "shouting". In examples such as this , when connection is established (namely, client obtains a Socket by calling "new Socket" and server obtains a Socket by calling "accept"), those Sockets are dedicated to those 2 specific endpoints. So if 10 clients connect to 1 server, the server will keep 10 Sockets and won't mix them up. A bit like a poor secretary that has 10 phones on his desk and answers them all - despite the mess, each earpiece is clearly connected to 1 customer.
The connection can hold for a while & serve several messages. It will terminate when either one of the sides calls 'socket.close', or it can be terminated by underlying 3rd parties (operating system, proxies, firewalls).
For your first version, or for simple business requirements, it's probably enough to converse over this 1 simple connection. However, for commercial critical data that requires 'assurance of delivery', you might need to invest some careful thought & possibly tools such as RabbitMQ.
Good luck:)
I have to write a Socket communication program to implement
Inter Process Communication.
I understand I need to have a client and server implementation.
Server implementation:
MyServerice = new ServerSocket(PortNumber);
Client and server will be on same machine so I don't want to interfere with any other running applications
How to decide which port number to use?
You can look at this table
those are mostly all, you will never know if any other external app is taking the port you have in mind, so in your case is a
Firt to come, first to serve issue
I think in implementing the websocket object, the WebSocket protocol communications typically use TCP port number 80, so environments that block non-standard internet connections by using a firewall will still pass WebSocket packets.
I'm trying to make like a skype-instant messager, my idea for it is to have
one server which handles multiple connections for the clients. What I now have is a friend list etc, but now I want to create Threads both for server and client to handle a conversation. The problem is that I need multiple connections between a server and one client for every conversation(I think). but i dont think it's possible. Does someone have another way for doing this or maybe a way to make multiple connections between the server and a client?
Thanks for helping me out
PS: English is not my main language so please excuse me for my grammar.
I think the best is that you always make one tcp connection from each client to the server, that way if your client is behind a firewall or router the connection can be established anyway.
Then you need to define a protocol with control messages, like "create new conversation with ...". And the server can generate a guid for each new conversation, then client can receive and send messages togheter with the conversation id always through one connection.
Update:
To answer the original question: yes, you can make multiple connections between client and server. Each connection should be opened from the client to the server port, once established, each one will have a different port. You can make a thread to deal with each connection or have on thread dealing with all connection using non-blocking calls.
I have created this game bot where it connects to the game, and starts playing.
My problem is that i can't start more than one of these as the other then won't work.
Is is possible that if i run 2 instances of the same program the sockets are interfering with each other ? After all, they do connect to the same IP with the same port ?
And sometimes after i close(just closing cmd) the program is unable to connect again. Is that cause i didn't close the connections right ?.
I hope this is enough else i'll just have to post my source code
Best regards.
It's possible to connect to the same socket/port several times. Actually a socket is a double peer: {client ip/ client port}{server ip/server port}. When you connect to a server, your client port is assigned dynamically. You will have a new and different client port per client. So it should work unless the server side forbid it.
You should have a server that listens for multiple connections. A server is bound to a port and once that port is in use another application cannot use it. So for the server just have one instance. Multiple clients can connect to this IP/Port as long as the Server accepts multiple connections.
If a client connects to the server and the other clients stop working this may be because the server does not support multiple clients. To do this you need to use multi threading in the server. The server should accept a client socket and create a new instance of a client with it's own StreamReader/Writer objects.
http://tutorials.jenkov.com/java-multithreaded-servers/multithreaded-server.html
if you are working with a specific TCP port, then there is a close-wait period that this port cannot be claimed temporariliy for some time. also multiple programs cannot listen the same TCP port. Use threads.
I am writing this game in Java and have problems with networking architecture.
I decided I will UDP packets. I am just at the beginning, but the problem I am facing is that it seems to be that server have to respond from exactly same IP/Port to client (which is behind router which uses NAT) as client connected that server.
For example I have client A behind router. Client A has IP (local) 192.168.8.100 and it connects server B from port 1234. Server is on 11.11.11.11:2345.
When client A connects to server B it uses 192.168.8.100:1234 but router converts that to (for example) 22.22.22.22:6789.
Now, when server wants to send packets to that client it has to be from 11.11.11.11:2345.
I would like to send data from another port like 11.11.11.11:2222, but this does not seem to work, at least not with my router.
I want to use different port because I want to have two threads one for listening and one for sending data, and each thread would have it's own DatagramSocket. But, as i said once client A connects to server on port 2345, I can not send data from port 2222.
Does anyone know how is this handled? I am doing it in Java, but it's not really a language specific problem.
UPDATE
After #Perception commented I have some more questions regarding his comments:
OK, so if I understand this correctly, if I have server which is hosting 1000 games, each with 2 players, all sending/receiving will have to be done through the same DatagramSocket.
As I understand DatagramSocket is thread safe so I guess I can have one thread doing:
datagramSocket.receive();
while at the same time second thread is doing
datagramSocket.send(.....);
Correct?
Also, two threads can send data at the same time through the same DatagramSocket? Is sending in any way serialized, meaning that second send() starts only after previous send() is finished or is data being sent at the same time?
gorann, I'm not sure if I'm understanding you correctly, but it sounds like you're trying to control the port on which the server communicates with the client. There's no way to control this, and for good reasons.
This is one of the trickier differences between TCP and UDP.
When a new TCP session is initiated, the server side call to accept() gives you a new socket and the OS handles multiplexing the various sessions for you. With UDP, you need to handle the multiplexing yourself. But you need to do so in a way that works with NATs and other firewalls.
The way NAT works is that when it sees an outgoing packet, it creates a temporary rule allow packets to return along the same port pair. Data returning from a port that the client has not yet sent to will likely be blocked.
This gives you two choices:
You could do all of your communication through a single port. This is not a bad option, it just means that you need a way to identify client sessions and route them to the appropriate thread.
You could create a separate port and instruct the client to send to that one instead. Have the server listen on a fixed port. The client sends a message to there, the server then sets up a new session port and sends that number back to the client using the server's listen port. The client then sends a message to the session port, which causes the NAT to open up that port and allow return traffic. Now the client and server thread have their own private port pair.
Option 1 is a bit more work because it requires data to be exchanged between threads, but it scales up better. Option 1 is easier and more CPU efficient because each session thread can be independent, but there are a finite number of ports available.
Either way, I recommend that you have the client include a semi-unique session id in each packet so that the server has more than just the client address and port number to verify who belongs to each session.