We Keep Coding

Best approach to dynamically load modules (classes) in Java

I'm currently writing an application that requires to operate on different type of devices. My approach would be to make a "modular" application that can dynamically load different classes according to the device they need to operate on.
To make the application easily extensible, my goal is to assign a specific path to the additional modules (either .jar or .class files) leaving the core program as it is. This would be crucial when having different customers requiring different modules (without having to compile a different application for each of them).
These modules would implement a common interface, while the "core" application can use these methods defined on the interface and let the single implementations do the work. What's the best way to load them on demand? I was considering the use of URLClassLoader but i don't know if this approach is up-to-date according to new patterns and Java trends, as I would like to avoid a poorly designed application and deprecated techniques. What's an alternative best approach to make a modular and easily extensible application with JDK 9 (that can be extended just by adding module files to a folder) ?

Additionnaly to the ServicerLoader usage given by #SeverityOne, you can use the module-info.java to declare the different instanciation of the interface, using "uses"/"provides" keywords.
Then you use a module path instead of a classpath, it loads all the directory containing your modules, don't need to create a specific classLoader
The serviceLoader usage:
public static void main(String[] args) {
ServiceLoader<IGreeting> sl = ServiceLoader.load(IGreeting.class);
IGreeting greeting = sl.findFirst().orElseThrow(NullPointerException::new);
System.out.println( greeting.regular("world"));
}
In the users project:
module pl.tfij.java9modules.app {
exports pl.tfij.java9modules.app;
uses pl.tfij.java9modules.app.IGreeting;
}
In the provider project:
module pl.tfij.java9modules.greetings {
requires pl.tfij.java9modules.app;
provides pl.tfij.java9modules.app.IGreeting
with pl.tfij.java9modules.greetings.Greeting;
}
And finally the CLI usage
java --module-path mods --module pl.tfij.java9modules.app
Here is an example; Github example (Thanks for "tfij/" repository initial exemple)
Edit, I realized the repository already provides decoupling examples:
https://github.com/tfij/Java-9-modules---reducing-coupling-of-modules

It sounds like you might want to use the ServicerLoader interface, which has been available since Java 6. However, bear in mind that, if you want to use Spring dependency injection, this is probably not what you want.

There are two scenarios.
Implementation jar's are on classpath
In this scenario you can simply use ServiceLoader API (refer to #pdem answer)
Implementation jar's not on classpath
Lets Assume BankController is your interface and CoreController is your implementation.
If you want to load its implementation dynamically from dynamic path,c create a new module layer and load class.
Refer to the following piece of code:
private final BankController loadController(final BankConfig config) {
System.out.println("Loading bank with config : " + JSON.toJson(config));
try {
//Curent ModuleLayer is usually boot layer. but it can be different if you are using multiple layers
ModuleLayer currentModuleLayer = this.getClass().getModule().getLayer(); //ModuleLayer.boot();
final Set<Path> modulePathSet = Set.of(new File("path of implementation").toPath());
//ModuleFinder to find modules
final ModuleFinder moduleFinder = ModuleFinder.of(modulePathSet.toArray(new Path[0]));
//I really dont know why does it requires empty finder.
final ModuleFinder emptyFinder = ModuleFinder.of(new Path[0]);
//ModuleNames to be loaded
final Set<String> moduleNames = moduleFinder.findAll().stream().map(moduleRef -> moduleRef.descriptor().name()).collect(Collectors.toSet());
// Unless you want to use URLClassloader for tomcat like situation, use Current Class Loader
final ClassLoader loader = this.getClass().getClassLoader();
//Derive new configuration from current module layer configuration
final Configuration configuration = currentModuleLayer.configuration().resolveAndBind(moduleFinder, emptyFinder, moduleNames);
//New Module layer derived from current modulee layer
final ModuleLayer moduleLayer = currentModuleLayer.defineModulesWithOneLoader(configuration, loader);
//find module and load class Load class
final Class<?> controllerClass = moduleLayer.findModule("org.util.npci.coreconnect").get().getClassLoader().loadClass("org.util.npci.coreconnect.CoreController");
//create new instance of Implementation, in this case org.util.npci.coreconnect.CoreController implements org.util.npci.api.BankController
final BankController bankController = (BankController) controllerClass.getConstructors()[0].newInstance(config);
return bankController;
} catch (Exception e) {BootLogger.info(e);}
return null;
}
Reference : https://docs.oracle.com/javase/9/docs/api/java/lang/module/Configuration.html

SPI with Guice error

So I've been making some kind of plugins API for a Java project (to load JAR files externally) and well, I wanted to be able to add any Guice module inside any plugin to my project's dependency graph.
What I did was have a PluginsModule and in the configure method scan for other modules in plugins and install them using Java's ServiceLoader.
I made a test plugin and made a module for it, I confirmed it did get installed. No problems at this point. The problems appear when I do anything inside that module, for example I bound some interface to an implementation in that plugin (just to clear this up, I did the same thing without the plugin and it worked so it's not a binding problem) and tried to inject it, configuration errors saying there was no implementation for that interface appear.
public enum StandardGuiceModuleScanningStrategy implements GuiceModuleScanningStrategy {
INSTANCE;
#Override
public Set<Module> scan(Path directory) throws IOException {
File directoryAsFile = directory.toFile();
File[] childrenFiles = directoryAsFile.listFiles();
if (!directoryAsFile.isDirectory()
|| childrenFiles == null
|| childrenFiles.length == 0) {
return Collections.emptySet();
}
Set<Module> modules = new HashSet<>();
for (File childrenFile : childrenFiles) {
ClassLoader directoryClassLoader = new URLClassLoader(
new URL[]{childrenFile.toURI().toURL()});
ServiceLoader<Module> moduleServiceLoader = ServiceLoader.load(
Module.class, directoryClassLoader);
moduleServiceLoader.forEach(modules::add);
}
return modules;
}
In that implementation of my GuiceModuleScanningStrategy, as I mentioned before, I did use ServiceLoader. Anyways, I also tried other stuff, like scanning the JAR file and checking for a Module, and seeing if it has a specific annotation.

All Guice Modules annotated with #GuiceModule, will be installed into a child Injector. All classes annotated with #AutoBind will be bound to all inherited interfaces. You can also name it, which would lead to a named binding and overwrite the interfaces, which should be used. And if you don't want to use all Features, just overwrite the StartupModule and bind only the Features you want or your own.

Reflections returning Set with null elements

I'm using Reflections to find classes that have an specific annotation. My project structure is the following
One WAR package:
WEB-INF/classes/...packages.../ClassAnnoted1.class
One JAR package that is included by the war that has a class that executes this code:
Reflections reflections= new Reflections(ClasspathHelper.forWebInfClasses(servletContext))
Set set= reflections.getTypesAnnotatedWith(CustomAnnotation.class)
CustomAnnotation is also present on the JAR package.
the set size is correct (ie if I have 3 classes with the annotation in my WAR the jar, the set size comes back as 3), but all elements inside it are null instead of Class. I need to get the class and check the annotation parameters inside the class of the JAR.
Anyone got any idea of why this is happening?
EDIT:
Reflections reflections= new Reflections("com.my.customAnnotededClasses"); //package that my annoted class is in
Set set= reflections.getTypesAnnotatedWith(CustomAnnotation.class);
Also does not work, in this case the set length is zero instead of the number of classes with the annotation.
EDIT 2:
Ok, the real problem was that I was packaging my whole application as an EAR so I had the following:
EAR
----> WAR
----> JAR
The jar was included in the EAR lib folder and not on the WAR lib folder. So the jar classes couldn't see the war classes, once i made the WAR depend on the JAR directly like this:
EAR
----> WAR
---------> JAR
It started working. But the original question still stands, there might be situations where I want the Jar classes included in the EAR instead of the WAR (if i have multiple wars that need to use my jar for instance).

I guess I can't do it using the reflections library. So I did it by hand:
public static List<Class<?>> getClassesAnnotatedWith(Class annotation, ServletContext servletContext) {
List<Class<?>> webClasses, jarClasses;
webClasses= getClassesAnnotedWithFromClassLoader(annotation, servletContext.getClassLoader());
jarClasses= getClassesAnnotedWithFromClassLoader(annotation, Thread.currentThread().getContextClassLoader());
for (Class<?> jarClass : jarClasses) {
Class<?> elementToAdd= null;
for (Class<?> webClass : webClasses) {
if ( ! jarClass.getName().equals(webClass.getName())) {
elementToAdd= jarClass;
}
}
if(elementToAdd != null) {
webClasses.add(elementToAdd);
}
}
return webClasses;
}
private static List<Class<?>> getClassesAnnotedWithFromClassLoader(Class annotation, ClassLoader classLoader) {
List<Class<?>> classes= new ArrayList<Class<?>>();
Class<?> classLoaderClass= classLoader.getClass();
while (! classLoaderClass.getName().equals("java.lang.ClassLoader")) {
classLoaderClass= classLoaderClass.getSuperclass();
}
try {
Field fldClasses= classLoaderClass.getDeclaredField("classes");
fldClasses.setAccessible(true);
Vector<Class<?>> classesVector= (Vector<Class<?>>) fldClasses.get(classLoader);
for (Class c : classesVector) {
if (c.isAnnotationPresent(annotation)) {
classes.add(c);
}
}
} catch (Exception e) { }
return classes;
}
I get the ClassLoader from my WAR package through the ServletContext object. There is also a protection in case a class is defined in both the WAR and the JAR with the annotation and same name (you should probably check if the packages are the same too though).
Note that you should probably never use this code in your own projects (maybe only for debugging). It involves reflecting the ClassLoader class to make the "classes" property public. This property might not exists in Java 9 for example, so beware. This might also have some security problems if you are interacting modules written by third parties.

i had one a similar problem. are you sure, you included the annotation-classes into your classpath? if they are not loaded, they will somehow be found but not really returned and without any exception or anything

The Reflections library gave me various problems. Now I am using the reflection part of the Guava library: until now, no unexpected behavior has occurred.
In any case, I think that it is very rare that the source of the problem is the Java classloader.
Maybe try to load the class CustomAnnotation.class before to use it in the Reflections API.

Your code should work on conventional environments.
However, in different environments, such as osgi, you get:
1) urls with different protocol (bundle/vfs/...)
2) different class loader.
In the first case, you should a) add the relevant UrlType (see the DefaultUrlTypes in Vfs for examples), or b) use different method to get the urls (see other methods in ClasspathHelper and examine the returned URL list)
In the second case, you should a) pass the customClassLoader to Reflections constructor or ConfigurationBuilder in order resolving will happen, or b) query the store directly reflections.getStore().get(TypeAnnotationsScanner.class)
see also #8339845, JbossIntegration

GWT: How to share a java Object (ie: EventBus) between two modules

I’m building a large application and I would like to split it in several modules like Core Module for initialization, users management, etc…, Customer Module, Production Module, etc…
I want to split it in multiples GWT modules (not using GWT splitting technique) and share an EventBus for broadcast some events like LoginEvent, LogoutEvent. I don’t want uses the code splitting technique because I want reduce the compile time and re-compile only the module that I modified.
This allow also to enable or disable a module by commenting the script tag in the HTML host page.
I’ve write the following code with using JSNI:
CoreModule’s EntryPoint:
private static SimpleEventBus eventBus = null;
public void onModuleLoad() {
export();
getEventBus().addHandler(MyEvent.TYPE, new MyEventHandler() {
#Override
public void onEvent(MyEvent myEvent) {
Window.alert(myEvent.getMessage());
}
});
}
public static SimpleEventBus getEventBus() {
if (eventBus == null)
eventBus = new SimpleEventBus();
return eventBus;
}
public static native void export() /*-{
$wnd.getEventBus = $entry(#testExporter.client.TestExporter::getEventBus());
}-*/;
CustomerModule’s EntryPoint:
public void onModuleLoad() {
Button button = new Button("Click me");
button.addClickHandler(new ClickHandler() {
#Override
public void onClick(ClickEvent event) {
getEventBus().fireEvent(new MyEvent("Button clicked !"));
}
});
RootPanel.get().add(button);
}
public static native SimpleEventBus getEventBus() /*-{
// Create a useless eventBus because the GWT compiler make a call to a null instance
var eventBus = #com.google.gwt.event.shared.SimpleEventBus::new()();
eventBus = $wnd.getEventBus();
return eventBus;
}-*/;
But I’ve the following exception in Firebug when executing in the browser:
uncaugth exception [object Object]
I copied also the MyEvent and MyEventHandler classes that implements/interfaces a customer event.
P.S.: I know also the technique that consist to comment the other modules references to avoid to compile it.

A simpler answer is to not use multiple entry points.
==========================================
If what you are trying to achieve is breaking you code into manageable units but want to use all of them in the same page, you can:
create an "Application.gwt.xml" module with an entry point (equivalent to your initialization module, if I understand correctly)
create "UserManagement.gwt.xml" module without an entry point class
create other XXX modules without entry points
To create a module without entry point just remove the
<entry-point class='xxx'/>
from your gwt.xml files except for the "Application" one
You then need to include these modules into the "Application" module using
<inherits name="com.yourpackage.Module1Name" />
<inherits name="com.yourpackage.Module2Name" />
You then need to compile all of them together in one GWT build for module "com.yourpackage.Application".
When you do that make sure that both the compiled *.class and the source .java files for all your modules are available on the classpath.
Your "Application" entry point just needs to initialize and use the objects from the other modules

You cannot share code between different GWT compiled modules, unless you make some parts of your code available via jsni and call these exported methods via jsni, like you are trying in your query.
But be aware that: first, shared classes would be incompatible because each compilation would rename the classes/methods in a different way, and second, each compilation would remove different dead code pieces.
So in your case the SimpleEventBus returned in your window.getEventBus exported method is not known in other modules, although the other modules are using SimpleEventBus as well
The easiest way to do what you want, is to use GWT-exporter. First select correctly the js-api you want to export in each module, how you want to name it, and implement Exportable and annotate methods conveniently. Second take in account which objects would you use for the communication, because some of then could be incompatible. I would use primitive types, javascript object, and functions which are supported in GWT-exporter
I think that with GWT-exporter, for shared classes, if you annotate them in the same namespace and you export the same methods, hopefully you could use then in all modules but I'm not sure.
So export a js API via jsni or gwt-exporter and transfer pure primitive or js objects between them.

You can use the Frames and setup communication between the modules via WebMessage protocol. It will help only if the modules in one page and modules in separated war.

Implementing Spring-like package scanning in Android

I'm attempting to implement a package-scanning feature, similar to Spring's component-scan, for the Android framework I'm developing. Basically, I would like to be able to specify a base package, e.g. com.foo.bar and retrieve all Class instances that have a particular annotation. I don't want to have to register every component with my framework as that would defeat the purpose of the auto scanning.
Based on my research, it seems that it's not possible with Java to retrieve resources given a package name using reflection. However, I briefly looked into the Reflections framework, and I'm wondering if there is an Android-compatible equivalent. If not, perhaps there is a slightly less obvious way to accomplish what I want to do.
I looked into the Spring source a bit to see how they achieved this, but I don't think what they are doing would work within the Dalvik runtime.
Update
Currently, the below code has been the best I can do to retrieve all classes that contain a specific annotation, but frankly it's a pretty poor solution. It makes some really unsafe assumptions about the ClassLoader plus it scans (and loads) all application classes.
public Set<Class<?>> getClassesWithAnnotation(Class<? extends Annotation> annotation) {
Set<Class<?>> classes = new HashSet<Class<?>>();
Field dexField = PathClassLoader.class.getDeclaredField("mDexs");
dexField.setAccessible(true);
PathClassLoader classLoader = (PathClassLoader) Thread.currentThread().getContextClassLoader();
DexFile[] dexs = (DexFile[]) dexField.get(classLoader);
for (DexFile dex : dexs) {
Enumeration<String> entries = dex.entries();
while (entries.hasMoreElements()) {
String entry = entries.nextElement();
Class<?> entryClass = dex.loadClass(entry, classLoader);
if (entryClass != null && entryClass.isAnnotationPresent(annotation)) {
classes.add(entryClass);
}
}
}
return classes;
}

I wanted to find all the subclass at runtime.
So I've been looking for android class scanning.
This is my final code from what I gathered in web.
You will get the idea.
public static void findSubClasses(Context context, Class parent) {
ApplicationInfo ai = context.getApplicationInfo();
String classPath = ai.sourceDir;
DexFile dex = null;
try {
dex = new DexFile(classPath);
Enumeration<String> apkClassNames = dex.entries();
while (apkClassNames.hasMoreElements()) {
String className = apkClassNames.nextElement();
try {
Class c = context.getClassLoader().loadClass(className);
if (parent.isAssignableFrom(c)) {
android.util.Log.i("nora", className);
}
} catch (ClassNotFoundException e) {
// TODO Auto-generated catch block
e.printStackTrace();
}
// android.util.Log.i("nora", className);
}
} catch (IOException e) {
// TODO Auto-generated catch block
e.printStackTrace();
} finally {
try {
dex.close();
} catch (IOException e) {
// TODO Auto-generated catch block
e.printStackTrace();
}
}
}

I share the opinion of Joop Eggen and find his approach a good one. In Android I try to avoid the usual web app features which lead to a long lasting application start. I do not use reflection or package scanning.
But if you want to .... if I understand it correctly you want to have an annotation for a class. Instead of using annotations you could also use marker interfaces (to just have more possibilites).
1) Look at
Annotation: Java custom annotation and dynamic loading
Has an implementation in the question which just answers your question.
Annotation: Scanning Java annotations at runtime
Interface: Find Java classes implementing an interface
Interface: Is something similar to ServiceLoader in Java 1.5?
Interface: How can I get a list of all the implementations of an interface programmatically in Java?
Interface: Since the approach is expensive, maybe the ServiceLoader is a compromise between execution time and comfort, since it loads only the classes given in the services file. On the other hand if only classes with a certain interface are in your package then the ServiceLoader isn't that faster.
2) AndroidAnnotations
I would prefer the way AndroidAnnotations work (maybe an integration in AndroidAnnotations is the preferable way): It automatically adds an extra compilation step that generates source code, using the standard Java Annotation Processing Tool. So instead of runtime scanning you execute code based on the annotations generated during compile time.
I think the Bean/EBean annotation could work for you (only single class): https://github.com/excilys/androidannotations/wiki/Enhance%20custom%20classes
A scan-feature is not available, see this thread
3) Writing your own annotation processor
See APT (Annotation Processing Tool). The idea would be to generate a static function which returns a list of classes which are annotated, so that no class scanning is needed.
A very good ressource is http://javadude.com/articles/annotations/index.html

Take a look at Vogar's ClassPathScanner. It uses it to find test cases on the class path.

EDIT:
I found this issue in the Android issue tracker. It appears that ClassLoader.getResource(String) is 'working as expected', in that it returns null. This is expected because the DalvikVM does not keep the resources around after compiling. There are workarounds listed in the issue, but there may be another way to access the classes you desire.
Use the PackageManager to get a hold of an instance of ApplicationInfo. ApplicationInfo has a public field called sourceDir which is the full path (a String) to the location of the source directory for that application. Create a File from this String, and you should be able to navigate to your package within the source directory. Once there, you can use the method from my original answer to find the classes you are looking for.
String applicationSourceDir =
getPackageManager().getApplicationInfo(androidPackageName, 0).sourceDir;
/EDIT
You should be able to use the ClassLoader.getResource(String) to get a URL to your specific package (the passed in String being the package name you are interested in delimited by path separators rather than periods). With this URL you can then call getFile(), from which you can create a Java File to the package folder. Call packageFile.listFiles() from there, and you have your classes/subpackages.
Be recursive with the subpackages, and with the classes find the Class object using the static Class.forName(String) method.

In your java build process incorporate the class path scanning, generating injection data/code. This could then be ported too to Dalvik. It is even more efficient that dynamic scanning.