A new HttpSession for each request? - java

I've always taken for granted the JSESSIONID cookie created for every fresh request for a given client when developing applications using the servlet specification. But after giving it a bit of thought, isn't is more logical for the servlet container to create a cookie header only after the session has been requested and created in code? For clients who have their cookies disabled, won't it end up creating a new HttpSession for each request made?
Please let me know if the question is still unclear so I can edit it. TIA.

A new Session will not be created by the Servlet container by default unless the Servlet actually creates it explicitly. Just because in the Header a JSEESIONID is being populated does not mean that there has to be a seesion on the server. An exception to this is in JSPs that by default create a Session if one is not there unless <%# page session="false" %>
As far as not having cookies turned on:
A web container can use several
methods to associate a session with a
user, all of which involve passing an
identifier between the client and the
server. The identifier can be
maintained on the client as a cookie,
or the web component can include the
identifier in every URL that is
returned to the client.
If your application uses session
objects, you must ensure that session
tracking is enabled by having the
application rewrite URLs whenever the
client turns off cookies. You do this
by calling the response's
encodeURL(URL) method on all URLs
returned by a servlet. This method
includes the session ID in the URL
only if cookies are disabled;
otherwise, it returns the URL
unchanged.

Related

what method is used by httpSession for session management in Java

I read lot of articles which says that there are different ways to manage the session like cookies, hidden form fields, url rewriting and jsessionId.
But when I do
HttpSession session = request.getSession();
Which method is actually used internally?
According to the servlet 2.4 specification:
Session tracking through HTTP cookies is the most used session
tracking mechanism and is required to be supported by all servlet
containers... To fulfill this requirement, Web containers commonly
support the URL rewriting mechanism.
Basically the session tracking (i.e. to keep the user interaction and sending the data ) can be maintained by 4 ways like HttpSession,cookies,hidden field and URL rewriting.
It depends on your requirement , which it needs to use.
If you are using HttpSession then you need to go for
HttpSession session = request.getSession(true);
As Cookies are client side.
Hidden fields are the form data you need to send to by request to servlet.
URL rewriting is used for sending the data using href or any link (usally GET method).
Session is used for secure and state full transaction.
Which method is actually used internally?
Its recommended to use HttpSession , if you want to track the request data over the application, until unless you invalidate that session. Jsessionid is a part of HttpSession. Internally Session is using unique Jsessionid for each session you are creating.
Hope it will help you.
The answer is that it doesn't depend on Java. It depends on the specific servlet container you are using and possibly the browser as well. If the brower won't accept cookies for example the container may be forced back to using URL rewriting.

HttpConnection maintaining Session

I'm consuming some web services done in java using a Rest architecture, my client it's a mobile application that uses HttpConnection to retrieve the data. In order to control authentication and authorization I'm using cookies, managed by a #SessionScoped class, however I don't know how to make the session persist through requests. The problem basically is that I inject the Session manager in other services that are #RequestScoped, however since the session is not persisted I always retrieve differente instances for the #SessionScoped class, thus deleting all the cookies or records I had before. Looking at the request headers I noticed the cookie JSESSIONID, I think this is sent by tomcat in order to persist session, so tried already to send the same cookie in the next request, however I got no results.
The comments were right... to persist a session you just have to send the JSESSIONID cookie back to server in the next request, the problem in this case was that HttpConnection in JavaME only has the setRequestProperty method to include a header value, now if you set the same value two times it overwrites the last one. Since I was using a custom cookie and the JSessionID cookie, I setted them in the following way:
connection.setRequestProperty("Cookie","sessionId="+ApplicationPreferences.getIn‌​stance().getSessionCookieHeader());
connection.setRequestProperty("Cookie","JSESSIONID="+ApplicationPreferences‌​.getInstance().getJavaSessionCookieHeader());
When the correct way to do it is concatenate the cookie strings and then setting a Cookie header with them all:
String myCookies="sessionId="+ApplicationPreferences.getInstance().getSessionCookieHead‌​er()+";"+"JSESSIONID="+ApplicationPreferences.getInstance().getJavaSessionCookieHeade‌​r();

Filter for checking session existence

I am developing a web application in Struts. I have a requirement that I have to check that a session exists for user. If the user session exists then user can access the resource, or I need to check session variable existence before accessing every JSP page.
For that I make use of filter where I check for the session variable existence. But when I use filter, every request is routed to that filter--even the login page request is routed to filter. The login page doesn't need the filter check applied, what to do for this?
This is typical session filter use case. For login page request, not to be filtered, you need have a different URL for login page which will be excluded in the URL mapping for the filter.
OR
In the filter itself, you can check what is the requested URL, its login page then don't check for the session. But I would recommend the earlier approach because its rightly address the Separation of Concern philosophy.

How do sevlet containers manage made up jsessionid(s)?

Could someone tell me what should happen if a client initiates a request to a servlet container with a made up (valid) JSESSIONID ? supposing the servlet doesn't have this jsessionid in its records (we're not hijacking a session, just making one up), will the servlet accept this session and use it for all subsequent calls or will it disregard it, make up its own jsessionid and return it to the client?
If a HttpSession cannot be found based on given JSESSIONID, it will just be ignored. A new one will be created whenever demanded by the code and a new JSESSIONID cookie with a new ID will be set.

Java HttpSession

Is HttpSession in java servlet is created only after
HttpSession s = request.getSession();
?
In my code I didn't write that, but when I use if (request.getSession(false) == null) ..., it doesn't work. Why?
A HttpSession is created when calling request.getSession().
But if you access a JSP by default it will automatically create a session.This behaviour can be disabled by using: <%# page session="false">
Are you using JSP?
Read JavaDocs, it says clearly:
This says, request.getSession()
Returns the current session associated with this request, or if the request does not have a session, creates one.
And the other variant request.getSession(isCreate)
Returns the current HttpSession associated with this request or, if there is no current session and create is true, returns a new session.
If create is false and the request has no valid HttpSession, this method returns null.
To make sure the session is properly maintained, you must call this method before the response is committed. If the container is using cookies to maintain session integrity and is asked to create a new session when the response is committed, an IllegalStateException is thrown.
Update
On a bit research, I have found that Session is not created unless request.getSession() is called somewhere. Since, The servlet container uses this interface to create a session between an HTTP client and an HTTP server. There are good chances that your Servlet container creates the Session for you by default.
refer:
Java Doc HttpSession
Discussion on JavaRaunch: is HttpSession created automatically?
But, to be safer side, use request.getSession() to get session, and use request.getSession(false) only when you need to verify if a session has already been created.
In addition to Nishant's answer note that session can be created implicitly by JSP pages unless you configured them not to create a session with <%# page session = "false" %>.
To make it complete:
session is not created, unless you call request.getSession(), in your servlet, use request.getSession(false) to get existing session without creating new session
if you use JSP page, session is automatically created for you - variable session - unless you specify <%# page session="false" %>
even if your session is created automatically, you can use session.isNew() to find out, if it has been newly created
Try to remove session cookies from browser and make another test. If it does not work then some other component is creating a new session before that call.

Categories