im starting with web services. I'm working in a project that needs to communicate Android with a web server and I'd like to save some time chosing the appropriate protocol for the communication.
Between JSON ,REST and SOAP:
Which ones can I run in a non-dedicated server?
Whats the best choice for a high trafic server?
Thanks in advance
JSON and REST are not mututally exclusive. JSON is a data format that the REST interface can return.
You may run either on a non dedicated server. I would personally choose REST for rapid prototyping on Android as it is easier to get up and running. (With SOAP you will probably want to have a schema which takes time to put together)
There's a good comparison between REST and SOAP on the REST wiki article: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Representational_State_Transfer#Concept
REST is more of a framework than a communications protocol. JSON and SOAP could be use to create a RESTful application.
If you're writing something with many resources, I'd use REST as it is far more structured. There are also a lot of libraries that will set most of things up for you. I find JSON and SOAP are better for custom functionality that you want to hack together quickly. They can be lightweight, but less structured.
Related
I've 2 questions about Java Rest APIs
1'st:
I would like to create a Rest API with Java Servlets for using in the mobile applications(IOS and Android)
and before doing that I would like to clarify the rest api content. However as much as I search through google all I found was automatic API creators from your Java code. But what I want is different first I want to document our Json Rest API so mobile and server developers can start to work independently.
Do you know any tool for that?
2'nd:
What I want to achive in our java server application is simple. Get simple json requests from mobile clients and do some database query and respond back with simple json objects.
For achiving this do I need to use any additional Rest API framework such as spring mvc (or something else) or just using Java Servlets and parse the request in doPost method and respond it there
Which one do you suggest?
Thanks
Restlet Studio (http://restlet.com/technical-resources/restlet-studio) or APISpark (http://restlet.com/products/apispark/) can bring you what you expect.
Restlet Studio allows you to define / design you API with a Web IDE: resources and their methods, representations (exchanged data structures). You can then have access to corresponding Swagger content and generate online client SDKs and even server skeletons for your API (this is internally based on Swagger Codegen)...
To implement your RESTful applications, Restlet can help you. It's a Java REST framework to access and / or implement RESTful applications. Restlet can be used within a servlet container with its servlet extension (see this link https://github.com/restlet/restlet-tutorial/blob/master/modules/org.restlet.tutorial.markdown/02_Server_Side/04_Server_Deployment/02_Servlet_Deployment.md).
Hope it helps you.
Thierry
I aggree with Stephan comment.
With Spring Boot and Spring Data Rest, the only code you will need to write is the mapping between your DB and your DAO Entities.
To document your API before writing it, you can use in fact any regular tools.
REST APIs don't have anything specific compared to others APIs to be documented.
Much of the documentation of APIs I've written were using Ms-Word...
Swagger provide a Json syntax to document a REST API, but it is mainly useful when used with Swagger-Ui, which allow to request the deployed server dynamically. You can use Swagger for your documentation, but as there will be no already existing server, I'm not sure it is worth the cost of learning its syntax. The main benefits is to give you constraints (like predefined fields) to follow.
By the way, I think that writing a REST Api Mapping or just document it takes the same amount of time, so I'm not sure it is really worth making all the documentation in a stand-alone way.
I am writing application in Java. It has 2 parts, server and client.
I need to communicate between server and client (secure using SSL). I don't have any other non-Java app connected to server (in long future too not), so I am not dependent on someone else's API.
Most of the data will be strings, numbers, and other "common" data types.
Is it good idea to use Java Serialization to communication between server and client? Or "good way" is use SOAP / XML / RPC / REST / ... ?
I found "Hessian binary web service protocol" is it good or is it waste of time?
Thank you for help. This is my first bigger client-server app.
Why do you want to restrict your service to java applications? It wouldn't be easier to develop and in the future you possible have to change it to other applications be able to communicate with.
I would suggest you to build a Rest Api serializing your data with JSON. It is simple and you can find lot of information about it, and libraries which do everything automatically, almost. To serialize the information you can use libraries like Jackson and to build your Rest Api Server you can use Spring MVC, you have a simple example here.
For the client you can use Jax-Rs 2.0 .
I hope it has been helpful! Ask anything!
What is the best way of save data using Restful web service without using Ajax? As a example I need to add a new Customer to the database using submit button.
What is the best way of transfer data format (text,json,xml) ?
How to read POST or GET data from HttpRequest object?
If you can please give me a example in java .
Thank you
I think you need to separate the concepts a bit. A "Restful Web Service" is a web service designed using REST principals, whereas AJAX is a set of technologies used often on the client side for asynchronous requests to multiple resources (without fully reloading the page). The web service really shouldn't care how the HTTP request is generated, just the contents of the HTTP request.
Now if you're concerned about writing a rest service in Java, I would highly recommend looking into JAX-RS and the reference implementation Jersey. There are lots of examples of how to get up and running. You can use MessageBodyReader implementations are to convert data from the HTTP request entity into Java objects.
Obviously this is not the only way to get started with writing a Restful web service in Java, but is one way.
It's very definitely worth your time to carefully study Richardson and Ruby's RESTful Web Services to learn the REST architectural style. In addition to #ach_l's recommendation to use Jersey, take a look at the Restlet Java framework, which is completely wonderful.
I just want to implement a service in java that will:
take some arguments, then search the database
return the JSON object of the fetched data
I need help to identify the ways through which I can implement this thing.
e.g. Suppose I am getting the name of the book as argument I want to render.
On service part, I have to fetch book data and convert it to JSON and write/return to response.
I was looking at the Apache Axis2 but I am not sure that I am going in the right direction.
So, pls help.
Need guidelines not implementation.
Thanks
I would suggest using JAX-RS based services which would be ideal for your scenario as you want json data. These are pretty easy to get started with. Jersey is a widely used frameworks. Also see RESTEasy.
If you are returning the data in JSON then you probably don't need to implement a full web service, which uses XML for both the request and the response.
A normal dynamic web application (written as a Java Servlet) will be able to read request parameters in the HTTP payload and return a JSON-encoded HTTP response.
However you need to consider your clients; if they are only able to access web services then you need to forget about a JSON response and simply objectify the response. However if the clients can access web resources without issue then go with the servlet approach.
If you need to go with web services then look at the Metro 2 framework.
One way to do this is to keep it standards-based.
If you are using the JEE5/6 framework, your best bet would be to go with JAX-WS - comes built-in with the JSE too (if I remember correctly)
You really just have to annotate a POJO with #WebService to achieve this.
Regarding creating a JSON response, a good bet is to stick with the implementation from http://code.google.com/p/google-gson/ ; simple and straightforward
Axis2 can handle/support the webservice related part, iaw, transforming java objects into JSON and vice-versa and providing an easy-to-use API for the communication part.
Hibernate or JPA could be useful for database related tasks, although it might be easier to just use JDBC to send some simple SQL commands to the database (especially if the database already existst).
I have a .net application which needs to expose a service consumed by a java client. The service can't be public. There should be some authentication mechanism for the client. What is the best way to do this? I'm new to web services and am confused by all the soap, wsdl etc. and have also heard a lot that it'll be a pain to get the two to communicate. Your thoughts?
Web Services are the one of the best approaches for interoperability over WEB. it's not that much difficult to create and use. It's as simple as Connecting to different databases and writing XML parsing in your code.
There are so many ways doing authentication. If you are using the IIS for deploying .net web services, then You can use Windows Authentication, Forms Authentication. These 2 are out of the box features of IIS. You can implement your custom authentication also. There are few compatible cryptography algorithms also for encrypting your data.
Without web services, it's very difficult to establish communication between Java ad .net.
You can give a try for JSON also. But i am not sure.
Hey check this video which gives you details. http://skillsmatter.com/podcast/java-jee/consuming-a-dot-net-web-service-using-java
I'd go for a simple REST interface using something like Jersey on the Java side, and a .Net JSON library to parse the data I consume.