If I were to deploy an application on Tomcat vs. Websphere, what are things that I need to consider?
Do I have to develop my Java code differently if developing in one app server vs another?
Edit:
I will be funneling people from a website into a web app that does credit card processing and e-signatures (cc processing and e-sigs are through separate services). That is its sole job
You cannot use EJBs on Tomcat (unless you add OpenEJB). If your WebSphere deployment uses EJBs, you'll have to remove them to deploy on Tomcat.
If you use any Java EE features beyond servlet/JSP engine and JNDI naming service you'll have to eliminate them from your app.
Tomcat accepts WAR packages. If you package your app into an EAR on WebSphere, you'll have to change it to WAR for Tomcat.
Both use JNDI for data sources. There might be some nagging differences in naming conventions, but if you stick to the standard they should be portable.
If you use any WebSphere specific code in your app, you'll have to remove it to deploy on Tomcat.
If your app is servlets, JSPs, and JDBC you can deploy on either one without any problems.
You can think as Tomcat as a subset of Websphere, so theoretically everything that works on Tomcat will work in Websphere.
But...Deploying in Websphere, in my humble opinion, is a terrible pain, while deploying in Tomcat just works. (And if fails, just delete temporary folders)
Without knowing the technologies you are using, that's all I can say.
Depends, what are you trying to deploy?
Tomcat isn't a full EE server--are you trying to deploy an EE app?
If you're just deploying a web app, it's more important to consider which version of the servlet spec/etc. each server implements.
Related
I know that Tomcat is a web server but why it is not an application server?
Any server needs to follow some specification. What is that spec?
Is it possible for apache to make the tomcat application server?
Also I have read in a blog that the tomcat do not have some lib to act as an application server. What are those libs?
Thanks
I've heard once the following explanation I tend to agree with:
There is a spec of JEE (Java enterprise edition).
Formally you can think about it as a bunch of pdf-s describing the behavior of various technologies that comprise the JEE stack (for example: JMS, EJB, JPA, JPA, JSF, CDI and so on and so forth) as well as deployment models (EARs for example).
Implementors of Application servers have to implement all those technologies and offer interfaces that can be used by the application developers. So teams that stand behind WildFly (former JBoss), Geronimo, WebSphere, WebLogic and so on have read these specs and implemented everything in there.
Now, Tomcat didn't do that, they've only concentrated on (primarily) Servlets/JSPs. These are web technologies, so Tomcat can't be considered as an Application server that implements the whole JEE stack.
In general Tomcat (as well as Jetty, incidentally) should be more lightweight than full JEE compliant Application servers, it should start-up faster and it memory footprint should be smaller. So Tomcat/Jetty call themselves web servers.
I understand that this answer can be considered as speculation, but for me it makes a lot of sense.
Bellow is my perceive:
know that Tomcat is a web server but why it is not an application server?
Here, Application Server is specially for Java EE Server，Java EE is a huge specific collections for Enterprice Application Development，So Application Server should implement most specifics of these, while Tomcat(or Jetty) is only a Web Server(More accurately，Servlet Container)，they only implements the specific about Web(such as Servlet Spec(JSR340), JSP(JSR245)). Therefore，Application Server is stronger than Web Server，but Web Server is more lightweight and enough to satisfy most web applications.
Any server needs to follow some specification. What is that spec?
Of course，it depends on that your Server want to provide what services(functions)，these specifications can view here.
Is it possible for apache to make the tomcat application server?
I don't think apache will make tomcat to be an application server. Now, there are some popular Java EE Server: Jboss，WebLogic, etc. Not all enterprices need a heavyweight Application Server, on the contrary, most only need a lightweight Web Server。
Also I have read in a blog that the tomcat do not have some lib to act as an application server. What are those libs?
Tomcat only need care the specs about Web，and implements them.
Hope for your help.
Can I deploy a Spring java application on all (or at least most) of JavaEE servers ? like Weblogic, JBoss, Webshpere, Tomcat, Jettty etc.
And is there is preferred Java EE server for Spring ?
Yes you can. And no - there isn´t. Errata: you can take a look at the SpringSource dm Server. Be aware that spring is not a java EE implementation. Read this post here.
Yes, you can deploy it on any server, and you can use it on standalone applications and even on mobile applications. It is in no way restricted to web deployment. It is not even restricted to java, there is Spring.NET and even a Python version. However, java and web servers are a common if not the most common use for it.
Currently recommended web server by VMWare/Pivotal (current owner of Spring) is VFabric tcServer, which is a Tomcat fork containing some extra tools and functionality. But server in itself does not matter, Spring is container agnostic.
There is no preferred EE server. VFabric tcServer is a servlet container, not an EE server. It contains "enterprise capabilities" instead, but that's not the same thing. As said however, you can use whichever EE server you want.
Is it possible to deploy ear (Jersey and Metro) archive in embedded Jetty? Google shows articles and manuals only about Jetty + JBoss.
As far as I understand, Jetty shouldn't have such a functionality.
That's because jetty was designed to be a web container only for Servlets and JSPs.
You can see the jetty as an alternative to the Tomcat web server.
So Jetty is able to process only web based stuff (read WARs).
JBoss on the other hand is a full fledged Java EE container, so it can handle ears as well.
What you've seen is probably embedding the jetty inside the jboss.
I know that Jboss has used tomcat for dealing with servlets and jsps internally, so it might be possible to switch the underlying implementation from tomcat to jetty.
Hope this helps
I'll add that many people deploying into things like JBoss or other full Java EE stacks really don't need the full stack and can often get away with a servlet engine plus a handful of components. I know folks that have gone with aggregated solutions of things like jetty + open ejb to achieve a lightweight stack that does what they need without all the added Java EE bells and whistles. For example, if you intend to have an embedded scenario then you don't need to deploy an ear you can deploy the application bit by bit, handling servlets with jetty and ejb's with openejb or whatever *bean solution you like.
If you need the full Java EE container then by all means use one...but if you are using a minor subset of those Java EE features there are other ways to assemble your application.
It seems that tomcat is a web application server and EAR cannot be deployed in it. Can it be updated to deploy EAR files. If not what could be the alternate server which is easy to configure and deploy?
In Short - NO. Tomcat is not a Java EE compliant server, but just a web server.
Use JBoss/GlassFish/Geronimo, there are a lot more, just google for it :)
Best alternative is Glassfish Application Server, alongwith Netbeans which will be best for practice purpose. Although there are a long list of such server and also that Apache also have one such server.
....
I don't know about Glassfish, but JBoss uses an embedded Tomcat so you might get comfortable with it somewhat easier.
I am currently developing an application for some researchers in my university.It's a small java program that you can use by command line. The next step is to package that program and deploy it to an application server. Some clients program will submit requests to the server who will call the tool that I wrote. Lately, we will add more tools to the server and he has to dispatch the requests to the right tool.
Which application server fits my needs ? I have looked for Tomcat, Jetty and Glassfish but it seems that they are only used for web application.
Is it possible to use those servers in some context different from web context? Which package archive should i use (jar, war) ?
Any advice?
Some clients program will submit requests to the server who will call the tool that I wrote.
The big question is what server-side technology and what communication protocol can you use between the clients and the server. You basically have two major options: HTTP and web services (in that case, consider using either JAX-WS or JAX-RS) or RMI-IIOP and EJBs (in that case, you'll have to use a Java EE compliant server like GlassFish).
I have looked for Tomcat, Jetty and Glassfish but it seems that they are only used for web application.
Not really. As I said, they can also be used for web services oriented applications. And GlassFish can be used for EJBs applications.
Which package archive should i use (jar, war)
The packaging will depend on the type of application you'll write, it's not something that you choose upfront, it's just a consequence. EJBs are packaged in an EJB JAR and typically deployed inside an EAR; Servlet based web services are deployed inside a WAR.
You really need to think about what technology to use first (with the current level of detail, I can't provide more guidance).
Do you even need an application server? There's nothing stopping you from adding the necessary network bindings and deploying it on its own.
Of the servers you mention, you've got 2 different categories: servlet containers and full-stack Java EE servers
Tomcat and Jetty are servlet containers. That doesn't mean that you can only do web stuff with them and you could manually add the required libraries to get a full Java EE server.
Glassfish is a full-stack Java EE server and can be compared with JBoss (both are open source) or the commercial rivals Weblogic and Websphere.
Sometimes this question is simple as the environment you are working in mandates a particular flavour of app server. You should check this first.
If you're not forced to use an app server, I'd ask why you think you need to use an app server?
I don't see why you would want to use tomcat, glassfish or jetty for a command line program.
If it's command-line based, and you want it to run server-side, you could write a little program that allows users to, for instance, telnet to your server, which in turn starts the CLI-application in question, and relays input / output to the client.
You may also want to look into Java Webstart, which makes deployment of new versions a breeze.
Actually we can't answer with so few elements.
- What are you planning to do
- With what technologies
- Where are you planning to host your application (have you got budget?)
- In which language are written the clients (even the future ones)?
- Could clients be on mobile phones (add some technlogy constraints...)
....
It would also be great to know what kind of request the clients will do, and what kind of response the server will provide...
Actually with what you tell us, all those application servers can do what you want...
I have looked for Tomcat, Jetty and
Glassfish but it seems that they are
only used for web application
You could even make a webapplication (servlet) and on the clientside use a httpclient to call that servlet... there are so many options :)
vive Paris!