I apologize if this is a simple question but I'm having trouble grasping the concept of modulus division when the first number is smaller than the second number. For example when 1 % 4 my book says the remainder is 1. I don't understand how 1 is the remainder of 1 % 4. 1 / 4 is 0.25. Am I thinking about modulus division incorrectly?
First, in Java, % is the remainder (not modulo) operator, which has slightly different semantics.
That said, you need to think in terms of integer-only division, as if there were no fractional values. Think of it as storing items that cannot be divided: you can store zero items of size 4 in a storage of overall capacity one. Your remaining capacity after storing the maximum number of items is one. Similarly, 13%5 is 3, as you can fit 2 complete items of size 5 in a storage of size 13, and the remaining capacity is 13 - 2*5 = 3.
If you divide 1 by 4, you get 0 with a remainder of 1. That's all the modulus is, the remainder after division.
I am going to add a more practical example to what "Jean-Bernard Pellerin" already said.
It is correct that if you divide 1 by 4 you get 0 but, Why when you do 1 % 4 you have 1 as result?
Basically it is because this:
n = a / b (integer), and
m = a % b = a - ( b * n )
So,
a b n = a/b b * n m = a%b
1 4 0 0 1
2 4 0 0 2
3 4 0 0 3
4 4 1 0 0
5 4 1 4 1
Conclusion: While a < b, the result of a % b will be "a"
Another way to think of it as a representation of your number in multiples of another number. I.e, a = n*b + r, where b>r>=0. In this sense your case gives 1 = 0*4 + 1. (edit: talking about positive numbers only)
I think you are confused between %(Remainder) and /(Division) operators.
When you say %, you need to keep dividing the dividend until you get the remainder 0 or possible end. And what you get in the end is called Remainder.
When you say /, you divide the dividend until the divisor becomes 1. And the end product you get is called Quotient
Another nice method to clear things up,
In modulus, if the first number is > the second number, subtract the second number from the first until the first number is less than the second.
17 % 5 = ?
17 - 5 = 12
12 % 5 = ?
12 - 5 = 7
7 % 5 = ?
7 - 5 = 2
2 % 5 = 2
Therefore 17 % 5, 12 % 5, 7 % 5 all give the answer of 2.
This is because 2 / 5 = 0 (when working with integers) with 2 as a remainder.
Related
This question already has answers here:
How to add two numbers of any length in java?
(8 answers)
Closed 5 years ago.
Today I had an interview and the interviewer asked to make a program for addition of two numbers, I get shocked how can he give a simple question but the question is different
the length of two number can be anything (10,20,30 or even 1000 etc.)
if you convert it to int,double,long double if the number is greater than their range than the answer can be wrong.
Please help me for the question.
You can always take the two numbers in arrays (i.e. arrays have digits of the numbers as elements) and add them as we add manually i.e. start from one's digit and store the carry if it's present then do the same for ten's digit, then hundred's digit and so on.
Say you want to add 123 and 329.
X = 123, X[] = [1,2,3]
Y = 329, Y[] = [3,2,9]
You start with one's digit (the rightmost or last element) and add the elements of both X and Y arrays and add carry to it (initially set to 0). If the addition comes out to be greater than 10, set carry = sum / 10 (since we are adding each element, this carry shall always be either 0 or 1) and the addition to add [i] = sum % 10. Repeat till all the elements of smaller array are over. Then add the carry to remaining elements of larger array continuing the above logic.
carry = 0
Step 1 : 3 + 9 + carry (0) = 5, carry => 12 / 10 = 1, add => 12 % 10 = 2
Step 2 : 2 + 2 + carry (2) = 6, carry => 6 / 10 = 0, add => 6 % 10 = 6
Step 3 : 3 + 1 + carry (0) = 4, carry => 4 / 10 = 0, add => 4 % 10 = 4
Ans = 462
Obviously the array storing sum may have one digit extra so take care of that as well.
So this was a question on one of the challenges I came across in an online competition, a few days ago.
Question:
Accept two inputs.
A big number of N digits,
The number of questions Q to be asked.
In each of the question, you have to find if the number formed by the string between indices Li and Ri is divisible by 7 or not.
Input:
First line contains the number consisting on N digits. Next line contains Q, denoting the number of questions. Each of the next Q lines contains 2 integers Li and Ri.
Output:
For each question, print "YES" or "NO", if the number formed by the string between indices Li and Ri is divisible by 7.
Constraints:
1 ≤ N ≤ 105
1 ≤ Q ≤ 105
1 ≤ Li, Ri ≤ N
Sample Input:
357753
3
1 2
2 3
4 4
Sample Output:
YES
NO
YES
Explanation:
For the first query, number will be 35 which is clearly divisible by 7.
Time Limit: 1.0 sec for each input file.
Memory Limit: 256 MB
Source Limit: 1024 KB
My Approach:
Now according to the constraints, the maximum length of the number i.e. N can be upto 105. This big a number cannot be fitted into a numeric data structure and I am pretty sure thats not the efficient way to go about it.
First Try:
I thought of this algorithm to apply the generic rules of division to each individual digit of the number. This would work to check divisibility amongst any two numbers, in linear time, i.e. O(N).
static String isDivisibleBy(String theIndexedNumber, int divisiblityNo){
int moduloValue = 0;
for(int i = 0; i < theIndexedNumber.length(); i++){
moduloValue = moduloValue * 10;
moduloValue += Character.getNumericValue(theIndexedNumber.charAt(i));
moduloValue %= divisiblityNo;
}
if(moduloValue == 0){
return "YES";
} else{
return "NO";
}
}
But in this case, the algorithm has to also loop through all the values of Q, which can also be upto 105.
Therefore, the time taken to solve the problem becomes O(Q.N) which can also be considered as Quadratic time. Hence, this crossed the given time limit and was not efficient.
Second Try:
After that didn't work, I tried searching for a divisibility rule of 7. All the ones I found, involved calculations based on each individual digit of the number. Hence, that would again result in a Linear time algorithm. And hence, combined with the number of Questions, it would amount to Quadratic Time, i.e. O(Q.N)
I did find one algorithm named Pohlman–Mass method of divisibility by 7, which suggested
Using quick alternating additions and subtractions: 42,341,530
-> 530 − 341 = 189 + 42 = 231 -> 23 − (1×2) = 21 YES
But all that did was, make the time 1/3rd Q.N, which didn't help much.
Am I missing something here? Can anyone help me find a way to solve this efficiently?
Also, is there a chance this is a Dynamic Programming problem?
There are two ways to go through this problem.
1: Dynamic Programming Approach
Let the input be array of digits A[N].
Let N[L,R] be number formed by digits L to R.
Let another array be M[N] where M[i] = N[1,i] mod 7.
So M[i+1] = ((M[i] * 10) mod 7 + A[i+1] mod 7) mod 7
Pre-calculate array M.
Now consider the expression.
N[1,R] = N[1,L-1] * 10R-L+1 + N[L,R]
implies (N[1,R] mod 7) = (N[1,L-1] mod 7 * (10R-L+1mod 7)) + (N[L,R] mod 7)
implies N[L,R] mod 7 = (M[R] - M[L-1] * (10R-L+1 mod 7)) mod 7
N[L,R] mod 7 gives your answer and can be calculated in O(1) as all values on right of expression are already there.
For 10R-L+1 mod 7, you can pre-calculate modulo 7 for all powers of 10.
Time Complexity :
Precalculation O(N)
Overall O(Q) + O(N)
2: Divide and Conquer Approach
Its a segment tree solution.
On each tree node you store the mod 7 for the number formed by digits in that node.
And the expression given in first approach can be used to find the mod 7 of parent by combining the mod 7 values of two children.
The time complexity of this solution will be O(Q log N) + O(N log N)
Basically you want to be able to to calculate the mod 7 of any digits given the mod of the number at any point.
What you can do is to;
record the modulo at each point O(N) for time and space. Uses up to 100 KB of memory.
take the modulo at the two points and determine how much subtracting the digits before the start would make e.g. O(N) time and space (once not per loop)
e.g. between 2 and 3 inclusive
357 % 7 = 0
3 % 7 = 3 and 300 % 7 = 6 (the distance between the start and end)
and 0 != 6 so the number is not a multiple of 7.
between 4 and 4 inclusive
3577 % 7 == 0
357 % 7 = 0 and 0 * 10 % 7 = 0
as 0 == 0 it is a multiple of 7.
You first build a list of digits modulo 7 for each number starting with 0 offset (like in your case, 0%7, 3%7, 35%7, 357%7...) then for each case of (a,b) grab digits[a-1] and digits[b], then multiply digits[b] by 1-3-2-6-4-5 sequence of 10^X modulo 7 defined by (1+b-a)%6 and compare. If these are equal, return YES, otherwise return NO. A pseudocode:
readString(big);
Array a=[0]; // initial value
Array tens=[1,3,2,6,4,5]; // quick multiplier lookup table
int d=0;
int l=big.length;
for (int i=0;i<l;i++) {
int c=((int)big[i])-48; // '0' -> 0, and "big" has characters
d=(3*d+c)%7;
a.push(d); // add to tail
}
readInt(q);
for (i=0;i<q;i++) {
readInt(li);
readInt(ri); // get question
int left=(a[li-1]*tens[(1+ri-li)%6])%7;
if (left==a[ri]) print("YES"); else print("NO");
}
A test example:
247761901
1
5 9
61901 % 7=0. Calculating:
a = [0 2 3 2 6 3 3 4 5 2]
li = 5
ri = 9
left=(a[5-1]*tens[(1+9-5)%6])%7 = (6*5)%7 = 30%7 = 2
a[ri]=2
Answer: YES
1 - 1
2 - 2,3
3 - 4,5,6
4 - 7,8,9,10
Given any number from 4 to 6 ,I need the output as 3.
Given any number from 7 to 10 ,I need the output as 4.
I need the fastest solution for the above problem to solve an algorithm.
What I could think of is a brute force algorithm :
Given 7:
n-square + n = 7*2 = 14
1 + 1 = 2 < 14
4 + 2 = 6 < 14
9 + 3 = 12 < 14
16+ 4 = 20 >=14 --> So 4
Is there any better approach to arrive at the solution ? OR My approach to the algorithm itself is flawed ?
Brief explanation of the algo :
A,B,C
After every iteration every element becomes increased by one.
A,A,B,B,C,C
Given 3, C will be returned.
Given 4 or 5, A will be returned.
Given 6 or 7, B will be returned.
Given 8 or 9, C will be returned.
Given 10 or 11 or 12, A will be returned.
Given 13 or 14 or 15, B will be returned.
How the solution to the mathematical problem will help solve the algo :
Total number of elements = 3
Given number = 13 (Output to be B)
Divide and Ceiling = Ceil (13/3) = 5 [So 13 falls under when every element has become * 3] (From Mathematical problem : If given number is 5, 3 is to be used)
Starting index of when every element has become * 3 [IS_EQUAL_TO = ] 3 * 3(summation of previous iteration => 1 + 2) + 1 = 10
To Find the index = Ceil(13-10+1/3 (this 3,comes from the mathematical problem) ) = Ceil (4/3) = 2nd index = B
Given number of rows N, the size of the triangle is N(N+1)/2. You are essentially trying to find the least integer N such that N(N+1)/2 >= M, with M given. If you have a function to compute square roots, you can solve this equation in constant time.
N(N+1)/2 >= M, multiply both sides with 2,
N²+N >= 2M, complete the square, take the square root, blablabla
N >= sqrt(2M+1/4)-1/2
Therefore the answer is N = ceil(sqrt(2*M + .25) - .5)
This question already has answers here:
Modulus division when first number is smaller than second number
(6 answers)
Closed 7 years ago.
I understand that a mod operator finds the remainder of two numbers. However, I am having trouble understanding the concept when the numbers are reversed. Meaning, a smaller number comes first in the operation.
int x = 4 % 3 ; // prints out 1
However, can someone explain this to me:
int y = 1 % 4 ; // prints out 1
int z = 2 % 3 ; // prints out 2
Thanks in advance!
Whether the left-hand side of the operator is larger than the right is irrelevant. There is always a remainder for any division operation, it's just that sometimes it's 0.
So 5 % 2 returns 1, just like 4 % 3 returns 1.
The value of any modulo operation of the form x % n will be 0 to n - 1 inclusive, for positive x. It will be -1(n-1) to 0 inclusive for negative x.
Are you sure about the int y that prints out 2?
The int z though seems normal :
2= 0*3 + 2
int y = 1 % 4 should print 1 because:
1=0*4 + 1
It works the same as when a bigger number comes first, you just take the remainder of the division of the first one by the second one.
(If there is already a question asking this please just send me the link in the comments. I did not find anything)
I was doing a small app, like MasterMind (but way simpler and not like it) and I wanted to help the user if he tried for example 5 times and didn't succeed.
int counter = 1;
while (flag){
System.out.println("Counter");
int guess = input.nextInt();
counter++;
if (counter>=5 && ) {
System.out.println("I'm helping");
}
}
if (counter>=5 && ) How do I tell it to help the user every 3 attempts how the fifth? Thanks
Every three attempts after the fifth, including the fifth?
if (counter >= 5 && (counter - 5) % 3 == 0 ) {
So say it was the 8th time, the if statement would be true because 8 - 5 = 3 and 3 % 3 == 0
If it was the 11th time, it would also be true because 11 - 5 = 6 and 6 % 3 == 0
The mod function (%) returns the remainder of the first number divided by the second number. If the remainder is 0, then the first number is divisible by the second.
For example: 8 % 3 is 2 because 3 goes into 8 twice, with a remainder of 2.
And 9 % 3 is 0 because 3 goes into 9 three times evenly.
Edit:
The reason I had to change add the condition that counter >= 5 for the second part is because if the counter was 2 and you subtract 5 from that, you get -3. Then, -3 % 3 will be 0 and the condition would be true, but that's not what you want. It has to be greater than or equal to 5, and every third number after 5 (inclusive).