My database background comes from the Django framework (python). In Django, getting started with database migrations was easy: Django migrations. The Django framework provided tool for creating the migrations based on your models, and also a tool to apply the migrations on your database. I think this way of doing worked in both development and in production. You did not have to write migrations by yourself, the framework created them for you.
Now I have started a project with Spring Boot and Hibernate. I configure my application to use hibernate with JPA. With these settings, I now would need to know how does my framework handle database migrations? I mean if I change a column, either it's type, or even might remove it, then how do I migrate the database to the change? I know that spring boot will automatically detect column changes on startup, and create columns that do not exist based on the models (Entity's). I guess it has something to do with variable
spring.jpa.hibernate.ddl-auto
But how does it handle the existing database objects? Does it add the column to them too, and with what value? The default value I set? What if I change the column type? Can it then handle the change? These settings and spring-boot automated database management probably are not enough in the long run?
What I want to know is, that what are the best practices on how to handle database migrations with Spring Boot and hibernate combination? I believe there is a standard how most of the people with this combination handle the migrations? I hope it is as easy as with Django... I know about flyway, but don't know if I really need it, or if it is used much with this combination of mine (including spring boot and hibernate).
Liquibase or Flyway are the two main options for versioning/handling database migrations. ddl-auto is quick and dirty, but it does not, nor can it, take into account everything that needs to be handled. THere's also the chance of race-conditions (two instances trying to update the DDL at the same time).
This answer goes into more detail about ddl-auto in a production environment, and why you shouldn't.
Hibernate: hbm2ddl.auto=update in production?
https://www.credera.com/blog/technology-insights/java/liquibase-fed-inconsistent-schemas/ has bit more info on the why/concepts.
Related
We have a java application which uses spring boot and hibernate.
There are many changes on entities and fields. That's why, I want to follow changes and rollback mechanism. So that, I need a version control system over database. I checked flyway and liquibase, but I think those don't solve my problem. Because my table creations and updates are handled by hibernate.
Is there any way to see which queries are executed by hibernate to change the database and which changes have occurred since the latest database change (I mean new table, column creation or refactoring)?
One way to do it (how we do it):
Use 2 databases. A reference database and a development database.
On the development database use hibernate to let it create the strucutre.
Once a development cycle is done you run liquibase diffChangelog on the reference database. It will create a changelog.xml with all changes that have been done by hibernate on the development db. Manually correct it (names, etc).
When your happy with changelog file and the development cylce is done apply the changelog onto the reference database.
Start your next development cycle and repeat.
That way you can combine the advantages of letting hibernate generate the schema and still use liquibase to have a versioned DB-Schema that is re-creatable.
Use those tools as those are dedicated for this purpose. Personally, I like Liquibase more but it's your choice.
Hibernate's schema creation mechanism should not be used in production as then your Java description of the entity would drive the creation of the tables resulting in an inefficient structure.
That feature is only there for testing purposes.
im building a Spring Boot web app with MySQL and till now i used the
spring.jpa.hibernate.ddl-auto=create-drop
in my properties file, and now i want to move to production and i cant use this line anymore because as u all know its saving the data on the memory and the worst thing its destroying all the data and create a new table every deploy.
for dev purposes its wonderful but what i need to do next cause i want it to behave exactly as i was on the ddl-auto but to persistently save the data and most inportantly never to drop the data.
P.S. the hibernate.ddl-auto has nothig to do with the JPA Repository?
cause i use Crud Repository alot and i need this to continue working with Crud Repository, will it?
the best thing to do, according to me, is:
use the option spring.jpa.hibernate.ddl-auto=create-drop to create
the DB schema and the default data (if any) in development environment
export the created DB schema in a normal DDL
give the DDL to DBAs to check if any improvement must be done (e.g.
add some indexes, review some FK etc..)
adapt JPA models after DBAs review
give the final DDL to the "production DBAs" in order to create the
final correct schema in production environment too
Regarding to your question:
the hibernate.ddl-auto has nothig to do with the JPA Repository? cause
i use Crud Repository alot and i need this to continue working with
Crud Repository, will it?
You can of course use the crud repository; this option will not influence your business logic
I hope it's useful
Angelo
You don't want to be sending DDLs around. You will end up trying to invent version control system for your scripts, by naming them specifically or putting them in folders, you will struggle communicating with DBAs, scripts breaking..
You want your database definition code to be a part of your code base so you can put it under version control (yes, git).
Try to use Liquibase for this. It will help you do automatic updates of the schema, data, everything db related, and it knows how to migrate your app's db, lets say, from 1.1 to 1.2 but also from 1.1 to 1.6. There are also other db migration tools like Flyway, you can look them up and play around.
I have been working on EER diagram model for my Mysql base for the last 7 days. It is a rather complicated model with lots of connections and attributes. Now i know spring boot automatically creates tables based on your entity classes(including foreign keys and other settings) if you use spring.jpa.hibernate.ddl-auto = update in your application.properties, but is it possible to create entity classes after providing good credentials to DataSource object based on tables withing schema?
Point is i would probably need another 3-4 days of back-end coding to create all the classes with all the attribute, relationships etc.
Given the fact it can only be done in one correct way, based on schema tables and it is not really rocket science. Why not do the thing just once?
There is this question Automatically create Entities from database
but 1. i am using spring boot not JPA project and second blog is no longer active.
Any hints?
Just figured it out. I used the hibernate perspective in eclipse to connect to a database, create a cfg.xml and run the project as hibernate configurations, create a new reveng.xml config and that will work. More detailed answer can be found in the article below.
http://o7planning.org/en/10125/using-hibernate-tools-generate-entity-classes-from-tables
Hope it will help someone!!
There is this question Automatically create Entities from database but
1. i am using spring boot not JPA project and second blog is no longer active.
Under the woods, Spring boot uses JPA and more specifically Hibernate since it has bad compatibility with other JPA implmentations such as EclipseLink.
Why don't you use Dali Eclipse plugin ?
https://www.eclipse.org/webtools/dali/docs/3.2/user_guide/tasks006.htm
It has a wizard with many options and it addresses well this kind of need. The real drawback when I use it and we cannot store our orm configuration. So, since you have many tables, I advise you to generate it in an incremental way your entities.
I was learning some JPA to teach to some java friends and I was wondering, how do you handle updates that comes after the creation of the db in JPA? Let's say I have a production environment where there's data that I cannot lose.
Some changes comes in and how do I apply that on my production environment? It there a way that JPA would only update the changes on the database?
Or do I need to manually create a SQL script to update my database?
Is there any other options?
[]'s
Rodrigo Dellacqua
Some changes comes in and how do I apply that on my production environment? It there a way that JPA would only update the changes on the database?
Nothing standardized. In other words, that would be a provider specific feature. For example, Hibernate has a SchemaUpdate tool that can (in theory) safely update a database schema. In practice, many don't use that on a production database (including me).
Or do I need to manually create a SQL script to update my database?
Using migration scripts (and maybe a database migration tool) is IMO the safe way to handle this and is the way to go on real life projects.
And again, some migration tools might provide support for a given JPA provider. For example, liquibase does offer Hibernate support and can diff your Entities against a database to generate a change script.
I'm currently working on a desktop application using JPA/Hibernate to persist data in a H2 database. I'm curious what my options are if I need to make changes to the database schema in the future for some reason. Maybe I'll have to introduce new entities, remove them or just change the types of properties in an entity.
Is there support in JPA/Hibernate to do this?
Would I have to manually script a solution?
I usually let Hibernate generate the DDL during development and then create a manual SQL migration script when deploying to the test server (which I later use for UAT and live servers as well).
The DDL generation in Hibernate does not offer support for data migration at all, if you only do as much as adding a non-null field, DDL generation cannot help you.
I have yet to find any truely useful migration abstraction to help with this.
There are a number of libraries (have a look at this SO question for examples), but when you're doing something like splitting an existing entity into a hierarchy using joined inheritance, you're always back to plain SQL.
Maybe I'll have to introduce new entities, remove them or just change the types of properties in an entity.
I don't have any experience with it but Liquibase provides some Hibernate Integration and can compare your mappings against a database and generate the appropriate change log:
The LiquiBase-Hibernate integration records the database changes required by your current Hibernate mapping to a change log file which you can then inspect and modify as needed before executing.
Still looking for an opportunity to play with it and find some answers to my pending questions:
does it work when using annotations?
does it require an hibernate.cfg.xml file (although this wouldn't be a big impediment)?
Update: Ok, both questions are covered by Nathan Voxland in this response and the answers are:
yes it works when using annotations
yes it requires an hibernate.cfg.xml (for now)
There are two options:
db-to-hibernate - mirror DB changes to your entities manually. This means your DB is "leading"
hibernate-to-db - either use hibernate.hbm2ddl.auto=update, or manually change the DB after changing your entity - here your object model is "leading"