final int a=5;
System.out.println(a+1)
prints 6 whereas System.out.println(a++) or a=a+1 and then s.o.p(a) would give error.
Why would it print 6 when final values cant be changed?
Both a++ and a=a+1 assign a new value to a.
a+1 does not: it just evaluates to 1 more than the value in a.
Evaluating the statements:
System.out.println(a);
System.out.println(a+1);
System.out.println(a);
will show that the value of a is the same before and after. Doing the same with a++ or a=a+1 in the middle statement (obviously making a non-final first) will show that a is changed.
This should be no more surprising than System.out.println(5+1) printing 6, whilst leaving the values of 5 and 1 unchanged.
Because you never modify a in your example. You print the result of a+1. If you print a afterwards you'll see that it is still 5.
It is basically
int a = 5;
int b = a+1;
System.out.println(b); // prints 6
System.out.println(a); // still prints 5
Related
I was going through some exercises but I am confused in this one:
public static int f (int x, int y) {
int b=y--;
while (b>0) {
if (x%2!=0) {
--x;
y=y-2;
}
else {
x=x/2;
b=b-x-1;
}
}
return x+y;
}
What is the purpose of b=y--?
So, for example, x=5 and y=5
when we first go inside of while loop (while (b>0)) will b = 4 or 5? When I am running the code in my computer b is 5. And the return is 3. It is really unclear to me. Sorry if I am unclear in my question.
int b=y--; first assignes b=y and then decrements y (y--).
Also take a look at the prefix/postfix unary increment operator.
This example (taken from the linked page) demonstrates it:
class PrePostDemo {
public static void main(String[] args){
int i = 3;
i++;
// prints 4
System.out.println(i);
++i;
// prints 5
System.out.println(i);
// prints 6
System.out.println(++i);
// prints 6
System.out.println(i++);
// prints 7
System.out.println(i);
}
}
The difference between a post-increment/decrement and a pre-increment/decrement is in the evaluation of the expression.
The pre-increment and pre-decrement operators increment (or decrement) their operand by 1, and the value of the expression is the resulting incremented (or decremented) value. In contrast, the post-increment and post-decrement operators increase (or decrease) the value of their operand by 1, but the value of the expression is the operand's original value prior to the increment (or decrement) operation.
In other words:
int a = 5;
int b;
b = --a; // the value of the expression --a is a-1. b is now 4, as is a.
b = a--; // the value of the expression a-- is a. b is still 4, but a is 3.
Remember that a program must evaluate expressions to do everything. Everything is an expression, even just a casual mention of a variable. All of the following are expressions:
a
a-1
--a && ++a
System.out.println(a)
Of course, in the evaluation of expressions, operator precedence dictates the value of an expression just as the PEMDAS you learned in grade school. Some operators, such as increment/decrement, have side effects, which is of course great fun, and one of the reasons why functional programming was created.
I believe b would equal 5 entering the loop because
b=y--;
When the "--" is behind the variable it decrements it after the action.
It's poor coding, as it can confuse new programmers.
The function, assuming it is passing by value, like in the example above (as opposed to passing by reference) takes a copy of y, decrements it, and assigns it to b. It does not alter the argument passed to the function when it was called.
Post increment
x++;
x += 1;
Post decrement
x--;
x -=1;
Pre increment : ++x;
Pre decrement : --x;
According to the Head First Java:
Difference between x++ and ++x :
int x = 0; int z = ++x;
Produces: x is 1, x is 1
in x = 0; int z = x++;
Produces: x is 1, z is 0
I am trying to do in Java:
int i=5;
while(i-- >0) {
System.out.println(i);
}
When running this program the output is:
4
3
2
1
0
I am very surprised to see 0 in output. I am new in development. Can anyone justify this?
In your while condition i-- > 0, the variable i is evaluated first and then decremented.
When i reaches the value 1, it will pass the loop test and then get decremented to 0. This is why the print statement shows 0 in the output.
Here is a mnemonic you can use to keep track of how the decrement and increment operators work:
int i = 5;
System.out.println("When i = 5 then:");
System.out.println("i-- is " + i--);
i = 5;
System.out.println("--i is " + --i);
Output:
When i = 5 then:
i-- is 5
--i is 4
Simply, because you compare i>0 and decrement i afterwards.
// If I is 1, you compare 1>0 and decrement i afterwards.
// This is how the postdecrement operator works
while(i-- >0) {
System.out.println(i);
}
the loop will behave like the following.
is i=5 > 0?
decrement i to 4
output i = 4.
is i=4 > 0?
decrement i to 3
output i = 3.
...
and so on
As you can see the value you compare to 0 is allways higher then the one you are outputing. This happens due to how the -- operator works. If it´s preceding to the i as --i it will decrement the variable i first and return it´s value afterwards. If it´s not preceding as in your case i-- you will have the value of i returned first and i beeing decremented afterwards.
Postdecrement/Increment operator works on the principle "Use first and then Change"
Initially value of i=5, when it enters while loop it will compare value of i first and then it prints the decremented value. Here i will show you each iteration along with checks performed in each iteration,
Now value of i=5(in memory), inside while(5>0), it prints 4.
Now value of i=4(in memory), inside while(4>0), it prints 3.
Now value of i=3(in memory), inside while(3>0), it prints 2.
Now value of i=2(in memory), inside while(2>0), it prints 1.
Now value of i=1(in memory), inside while(1>0), it prints 0.
Hope now you are clear to go ahead. Gud Luck.
The post-decrement operator -- is like a post-paid service. Like a credit card, first you use, then you pay.
I thought I can give you a real-life idea of what really is occurring in this statement, when i == 1
while(i-- >0)
So, first you check if i(1)>0. 1>0 So, yes it is. Right after this statement is done, i becomes 0. Then, you print that value.
Alternatively, you might also get this intuition by noticing that although your loop started with i=5, the value 5 never got printed.
Since you are using the post-decrement operator in the while loop, when i is 1, i-- returns 1, and then inside the loop you get 0 when you print i for the last time.
Only because of post decrement operator (i--) will check the condition first then decrease the value of i. Output is giving such. Thank you
int i=5; //initialize with 5
while(i-- >0) { //post decrements operator so, check condition first then decrease the value.
System.out.println(i);
}
In first iteration of while loop will check 5 > 0 will be checked after that decrease the value of i and i will become 4 So, Print it 4 not 5.
When i = 5 conditional statement will be (5>0) (true) and print 4.
i = 4 conditional statement will be (4>0) (true) and print 3.
i = 3 conditional statement will be (3>0) (true) and print 2.
i = 2 conditional statement will be (2>0) (true) and print 1.
i = 1 conditional statement will be (1>0) (true) and print 0.
Now, i became 0 so conditional statement will be (0>0) (False).
So, loop exits.
To get desired output try this
while(--i >0) {
System.out.println(i);
}
What happens if you change the variable b, or what if you change a. What does the order have to do with anything.
I know count = count + 1 but the two variables is messing up my brain.
b = 7;
a = 7;
a = b;
a += 1;
What happens to b?
What happens to b?
Nothing happens to b.
When you do
a = b;
you're copying the value stored in b and putting it in a. (You're not making a an alias of b.)
When you then do a += 1; you're changing the value stored in a (and the value stored in b remains unchanged).
You can verify this by printing the final values after your code snippet:
System.out.println(a); // prints 8
System.out.println(b); // prints 7
What happens if you change the variable b, or what if you change a. What does the order have to do with anything.
a and b are two independent variables and changing one will never affect the other.
The order matters since when you do a = b the value of b is copied into a and whatever a stored before is discarded. If you had done a += 1 prior to a = b, then a would have been restored to 7 again.
int is raw type you don't copy reference but the value itself. This will work same way for Integer because it is immutable class.
int b = 7;
int a = 7;
a = b;
a+=1;
System.out.println(a);// ->8
System.out.println(b);// ->7
Still 7.
integer is raw type and if you assign a int variable to another int, just its value is received by the new one. Not the object itself.
b stays 7.
a becomes 8.
You could use System.out.println(); to print values of variables and find out yourself if you ever doubt.
That or use the debugger.
public static void main(String[] args) {
int b = 7; // b points to 7
int a = 7; // a points to 7
a = b; // b and a points to 7
a += 1; // a points to 8 now, b is still pointing to 7
System.out.println(a);
System.out.println(b);
}
output
8
7
When we do a += 1; we change the value stored in a (value stored in b is still same).
I'm having trouble understanding what happens to this piece of code when it returns. After it outputs 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 why does it outputs 1 after 0 and not 0 again?
public static void a(int b){
if(b<0)
return;
System.out.println(b);
a(b-1);
a(b+1);
}
Well you have a(b+1) that means there is no end condition for this case which means StackOverflow. as pointed out in the comment, it is stuck between 0 and 1
If b is less than 0, the execution of the method stops. The Code below the return statement will not be executed.
While this particular example returns a StackOverflowError I don't think that's the kind of answer you're looking for. So pretending that error-causing line wasn't there let me demonstrate what is happening:
public static void a(int b){
if(b<0)
return;
System.out.println(b);
a(b-1);
a(b+1); //assuming this didn't go to infinity
}
The method runs exactly like it reads, but you create sub-tasks.
It checks the if statement, then prints the value of b. Then it runs a(b-1) and then runs a(b+1).
You're getting odd results because then it runs a(b-1) is actually a series of tasks in and of itself. THAT method does all the things I mentioned before and they will all happen BEFORE the first instance ever reaches a(b+1).
Lets say you called a(1);
1 is not less than 0
print 1
a(1-1) //which is zero a(0)
//begin sub-task a(0)
0 is not less than 0
print 0
a(0-1) // which is -1
//begin sub-task a(-1)
-1 is less than 0 so return
a(0+1)
1 is not less than zero
print 1
a(1-1) // which is zero
zero is not less than zero
print zero
a(0-1)
etc. etc.
It may be easier to think of this as
public static void a(int b){
if(b<0)
return;
System.out.println(b);
a(b-1);
System.out.println(b + " is done");
}
This does the following with a(1);:
if(1 < 0) // false
print 1
begin a(1-1) or a(0)
if(0 < 0) // false
print 0
begin a(0-1) or a(-1)
if(-1 < 0) //true so return IE go back to the calling method
print "0 is done"
print "1 is done"
A stack overflow. The call to a(b+1) every time means there will never be a point where the original function can return, or the call to a(b+1), or the call to a(b+1+1) and so on.
The return in this case just finishes the current function/method call, popping things out of the stack and going back up to the previous method call. In other words, that's just your (incomplete) base case. Unless you add a termination condition for the case where b increases, the current base case won't be enough to say stop all recursion and you'll get a SO exception.
This question already has answers here:
Closed 10 years ago.
Possible Duplicate:
post increment operator java
What is x after “x = x++”?
Can somebody explain me the result of each one of the following small programs? :
public static void main(String[] args) {
int a = 10;
a = a++;
System.out.println(a);
}
The result is: 10
Why not 11 since a should have been increased after the assignment? Is that the fact that it comes to different variables left and right of the opeartor = ?
The next one:
public static void main(String[] args) {
int a = 10;
a = ++a;
System.out.println(a);
}
The result is: 11
Comprehensible, but the compiler presents the warning: "The assignment to variable a has no effect". The result dissents though.
Update:
I do not modify my original question but I add this comment to clarify that now I catch the meaning of the warning. That is, even without the assignment (by a plain statement ++a) the result would be the same (11).
The value of a++ is a. ++ has higher precedence than =. So:
The value of a is taken.
a is incremented.
The value as at (1) is stored into a.
So the value of a doesn't change.
You can figure out yourself what happens in the second case.
In first case assignment happens first and then increment. So you get value which was before increment. But in second case it gets incremented first and then gets assigned.
Lets analyze the Byte code produced in each way -
int a = 10;
a = a++;
System.out.println(a); //Output - 10
produced ByteCode -
0 bipush
2 istore_1
3 iload_1
4 iinc
7 istore_1
8 getstatic
11 iload_1
12 invokevirtual
15 return
and
int a = 10;
a = ++a;
System.out.println(a); //Output -11
Here compiler give warning - The assignment to variable a has no effect
Produced ByteCode -
0 bipush
2 istore_1
3 iinc
6 iload_1
7 istore_1
8 getstatic
11 iload_1
12 invokevirtual
15 return
Here we can see in 1st case variable load first then increment so it does not effect anything to variable a.
Where as 2nd case it first increment then load the variable so it got effect of increment.
This happens because a++ is more like a Method then a realistic Number.
you can splitt them into two seperat lines.
the first one would be
a = a;
return a + 1;
the seconde one would be
a = a+1;
a++ means increase the value of variable a, however a++ has the original value of a!
a = ?? means set the value of a to ??
So what you are doing is incrementing the value of a by one, and then setting it to the old value.
++a means increase the value of variable a, however ++a has the new value of a!
So in the second example you are incrementing the value of a, and then setting the value of a to that value (it has just gotten), so you are doing the same twice.
a++ is equivalent to a = a + 1 but increments after the value is used in expression (assignment here) ++a is same but increments before its used in expression. a = ++a; has no explicit assignment affect as it is equal to a = a = a + 1
When you write a++ it means a will increment AFTER the '=' operator has been processed. So
b = a++;
System.out.println(a);
System.out.println(b);
Should produce on your screen: 11, 10. Because a becomes 11 after b takes the value of 'a'. If you change the a++ to ++a you force the increment to happen before the '=' is processed so you will be giving b = a + 1 and on your screen you should be having 11,11.